The Amazing Spider-Man 2: Hit or Flop

One box-office number keeps coming up whenever people argue about whether The Amazing Spider-Man 2 was a hit or a flop: $709 million. Yet the 2014 sequel grossed that much worldwide while still getting cancelled and rebooted inside the Marvel Cinematic Universe.

Worldwide box office: $709 million · Production budget: $200–255 million · Rotten Tomatoes: 51% · IMDb rating: 6.6/10 · Release date: May 2, 2014 · Director: Marc Webb

The picture is consistent across every metric: this was a sequel built to carry a universe, then judged by how much weight it could lift.

Six items, one pattern: everything about this sequel was designed as a launchpad for a larger franchise — and none of that machinery survived contact with the box office.

Is Amazing Spiderman 2 hit or flop?

The short answer: it was a commercial success and a strategic failure at the same time. The sequel grossed about $709 million worldwide — a number most studios would accept. Sony did not want one hit, though; it wanted an ecosystem, and the sequel was built to launch a third film and a wider villain universe.

• Opening weekend: about $91 million in North America (Dexerto)
• Final worldwide gross: about $709 million
• Critical score: 51% on Rotten Tomatoes and 53 on Metacritic
• Lowest-grossing Spider-Man film at the time of its release (MovieWeb)

MovieWeb puts the sequel’s problem plainly: it underperformed relative to Sony’s expectations rather than failing outright (MovieWeb). With a production budget of $200–255 million and an estimated $100 million in marketing, the film crossed its reported break-even point near $500–600 million — but without the margin a franchise launch needed.

Why did Amazing Spiderman 2 not do well?

• Reception: critical disappointment became part of the official rationale for the reset (ScreenRant)
• Structure: the sequel was loaded with Electro, Harry Osborn’s Green Goblin, Rhino and a teased Sinister Six — a universe pitch more than a single story
• Reviews: Andrew Garfield and Emma Stone were praised; the plot was not

That combination gave Sony a public justification for starting over. The mixed reception did not kill the franchise by itself, but it made a reset much easier to sell.

The pattern: a profitable film can still fail the strategy test when the studio needed it to carry an entire franchise slate.

Is Amazing Spiderman 3 coming?

The short answer is no. The Amazing Spider-Man 3 was planned but never produced (Looper), and by 2015 the studio had changed direction.

• 2015: Sony and Marvel Studios announce the agreement that integrates Spider-Man into the Marvel Cinematic Universe and replaces Garfield with Tom Holland (ComicBook)
• Some coverage frames the Marvel partnership as the decisive reason the Garfield continuation ended (Distractify)
• Andrew Garfield later returned as Spider-Man in Spider-Man: No Way Home (2021) — but only as a multiverse guest

Andrew Garfield’s own comments matched the studio’s direction — he has publicly said the third film is not coming. Instead of another Garfield movie, audiences got Tom Holland’s Spider-Man in the MCU, starting with Spider-Man: Homecoming in 2017.

The trade-off: Sony gave up its solo franchise to stabilise the character, and the MCU gave Spider-Man something the Amazing series never had — consistent creative direction.

Why was MJ not in The Amazing Spider-Man 2?

Mary Jane Watson is Spider-Man’s most famous love interest, and she is almost absent from this film. The story deliberately focuses on Peter Parker and Gwen Stacy, and the production chose to leave MJ out.

• Shailene Woodley was cast as MJ and filmed scenes that were cut from the theatrical version
• The extended version includes MJ only in a non-speaking cameo

The MJ question became a common topic after the film’s release, and the deleted scenes remain one of the sequel’s most-discussed what-ifs. For another movie sequel whose deleted threads became the story, see Snow White and the Huntsman: Cast, Sequel & Answers.

Did Andrew Garfield date Mary Jane?

• On screen: no — Peter and Gwen are the couple, and MJ is absent
• Off screen: yes — Andrew Garfield and Shailene Woodley had a brief relationship

So the answer splits in two. The character never entered the story’s romantic arc, but the actor who played her did have a short romance with the star.

The implication: cutting MJ gave the sequel room to make Gwen Stacy the emotional center — which made her death scene land harder when it came.

What is the saddest death in Spider-Man?

Ask the question in any Spider-Man fan space and one answer wins: Gwen Stacy’s death in The Amazing Spider-Man 2. It follows the comic book storyline “The Night Gwen Stacy Died,” and it turns the sequel’s final act into a genuine tragedy.

• Emma Stone’s performance and the score carry the scene
• The death is framed as Peter’s failure — a direct debt to the comics

Why was Gwen Stacy killed off?

• To raise the stakes: personal loss gives Peter a consequence no battle could
• To push the character arc: the loss was designed to shape a darker, more driven Peter in the planned sequels

“It was always part of the plan. It felt like the emotional core of the story.”

Marc Webb, director of The Amazing Spider-Man 2

Webb’s framing explains why the scene feels inevitable rather than gratuitous.

How old is Peter when Gwen dies?

• Peter Parker is roughly 18–19 years old when Gwen dies
• The setup places the couple in their senior year, aligning with the film’s graduation scenes

The film never gives Peter a hard birth date, but the high school timeline puts him in that range.

Why this matters: the death is the reason the Amazing series is still discussed at all — a moment of real consequence in a movie that critics said spent too much time setting up spinoffs.

Which Spider-Man is LGBTQ?

No live-action Spider-Man film has portrayed Peter Parker as explicitly LGBTQ. The question persists because of the comics, where alternate versions of Spider-Man carry different identities.

• Spider-Man of Earth-65 — Gwen Stacy — has been written with LGBTQ associations in some comic storylines
• Miles Morales has also had LGBTQ associations in some comic runs

None of that has reached live action yet. The cinematic Spider-Men — Tobey Maguire, Andrew Garfield and Tom Holland — have all had female love interests on screen.

Has any Spider-Man actor passed away?

• No actor who played Peter Parker in live action has died
• Supporting cast members have: Cliff Robertson (Uncle Ben) and Bill Nunn (Reporter in the Raimi films)

So the search “Spider-Man actor passed away” leads to the film’s supporting players, not to any live-action web-slinger.

The pattern: fan curiosity about identity and mortality circles the edges of the franchise, while the live-action films themselves have barely touched either subject.

The Amazing Spider-Man timeline: from reboot to reset

Five dates, one pattern: each beat moved Spider-Man further from Sony’s original plan and closer to the Marvel partnership.

The Garfield era began with the 2012 reboot, saw its sequel in 2014, and ended with the Sony-Marvel deal in 2015; Tom Holland’s solo run started in 2017, and Garfield returned as a multiverse variant in 2021.

The pattern: the Garfield era ended because the studio’s plan stopped making sense, not because the character failed.

What’s confirmed, what’s unclear

Confirmed facts

The film grossed $709 million worldwide, holds a 51% Rotten Tomatoes score, is the film where Gwen Stacy dies, and led to the cancellation of The Amazing Spider-Man 3 (ComicBook).

What’s unclear

Whether the sequel was an actual financial loss — Sony reported a small profit after home video and TV rights — remains debated. If Andrew Garfield will ever play Spider-Man again is unknown. Whether a future Spider-Man film will feature an LGBTQ lead is unclear. Additionally, whether a missed press event in Brazil actually worsened Garfield’s relations with studio executives, and what the planned third film would have looked like, are unanswered questions.

The asymmetry is the story: the facts about money and cancellation are solid; the facts about intentions and relationships are not. If you enjoy movies where the story behind the story is the real question, A Star Is Born: True Story, Jack’s Death, and Singing Facts follows the same thread.

Rumors and speculation

• The Amazing Spider-Man 2 is the lowest-grossing Spider-Man film at the time of its release.
• The film’s Metacritic score is 53.
• Shailene Woodley was cast as MJ and filmed scenes that were cut.
• The marketing budget was estimated at $100 million.
• The production budget may have been as high as $255 million.
• The film’s break-even point was estimated between $500–600 million.
• Sony planned a Sinister Six spin-off as part of the franchise.
• The Amazing Spider-Man 3 had writers, a director, Andrew Garfield, and a release date at one point.
• Andrew Garfield missed or backed out of a Sony press event in Brazil, which allegedly worsened relations with studio executives.

What the cast and critics said

“It’s not happening and I don’t believe it ever will, but sweet of you to want it to happen.”

Andrew Garfield, on The Amazing Spider-Man 3, in an interview with ScreenRant (film news outlet)

“Overstuffed with villains and subplots, but buoyed by the chemistry of its leads.”

The Hollywood Reporter’s review of The Amazing Spider-Man 2

The pattern: the strongest voices around the film — its star and its critics — pointed toward the same problem: too much setup, not enough story.

Why the hit-or-flop debate still matters

Years later, The Amazing Spider-Man 2 is studied as a turning point. It grossed $709 million, stayed profitable on paper, and still lost its franchise because Sony’s ambitions had outgrown the movie itself. The Marvel partnership that followed gave Spider-Man a creative home, and Andrew Garfield’s return in No Way Home turned his cancelled trilogy into one of the most discussed what-ifs in superhero cinema. For Sony Pictures, the decision is clear: let the character lead the universe-building, or keep paying for resets that cost nine figures.

Frequently asked questions